18" Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza & 20 Wings $31.99

What our guest say about us

Facebook - Andrew J - 5 stars

Great NY style pizza like it should be. Thin, but it still stays straight. A little bit of grease covered by the awesome cheese. Def made right.

Google - Shan S - 5 stars

We love New York Pizza here on Fleming Island. The Pizza is so delicious! And I love their Caprese Salad too.Everyone that works there is so courteous. The restaurant is always clean too. The hours are convenient and so is Delivery.

Yelp - Don F - 5 Stars

Man, where to start. Came here because of the overwhelmingly positive yelp reviews. Usually, when I see a place rated really high I'm eager to try it, but skeptical at the same time. I'm always afraid of getting my hopes too high, and being let down. This place left me floored with how good it was My wife and I both got pizza rolls, and my son chicken wings. The pizza rolls were HUGE and amazing. Absolutely the best I've had. The wings were crispy and flavorful. The customer service was even better than the food. This place just earned a spot in our regular rotation. A return customer has been born

Visit Us

Special Requests?

Do you have dietary concerns? Questions about an upcoming event? Drop us a line, and we'll get back to you soon!

New York Pizza

1811 Golden Eagle Way Suite 25, Fleming Island, Florida 32003, United States

(904) 579-3488


Monday -Thursday: 10:30am- 9pm

Friday & Saturday: 10:30am-10pm

Sunday: 12pm-9pm

Contact Us